|
"The most
important question: To the extent that a relationship exists
between the details of a work and its large-scale structure,
what are the means by which this relationship is made audible?
It is not enough to discover the score, when indeed it exists.
We must be able to claim that we have always heard it--perhaps
without being conscious of it, but in sensing its effect on
our perception of the work".
Rosen (1971, p. 49).
"Que serait une oeuvre dont chaque partie, loin de
concourir à former un tout cohérent pourrait être
supprimée, remplacée, transplantée ?"
Hodeir, 1951
The large-scale organization of tonal works is defined by the unfolding
of melodic and harmonic structures. The researchers task is to show
that these structures , which are first perceived locally, are subsequently
integrated into a larger organizational unit. In other words, we
must determine if listeners perceive musical works as a series of
locally structured groups, or it they succeed in joining them into
something larger.
|

Piece A
|

Piece B
|
Many musicologists emphasize the importance of large structures
in music. A musical phrase, however beautiful it may be in itself,
only reaches its expressive summum when it is in perfect harmony
with all that surrounds it. What would we say of a work whose separate
parts, instead of working together to form a coherent whole, could
be removed, replaced or re-positioned? To what extent does piece
A strike you as less expressive than piece B?
Bibliography
Tillmann, B., Bigand, E., & Madurell, F. (1998). Influence of Global and Local Structures on Solution of Musical Puzzles. Psychological Research, 61, 3, 157-175. Pdf
Tillmann, B., & Bigand, E. (1998). Influence of global structure on musical target detection and recognition. International Journal of Psychology. 33, 107-122. Pdf
Tillmann, B., & Bigand, E. (1996). Does formal musical structure affect perception of musical expressiveness? Psychology of Music, 24, 3 - 17.
|